Occupational Balance: do we practise what we preach?

Walking into the hospital where I work this morning I noticed a sign telling anybody with respiratory tract infection symptoms to stay away, to avoid infecting patients. I walked past the sign with a small cough and then blew my nose at the first available discreet opportunity. It seemed like the sign did not apply to me; it only applied to the public. During my first hour at work today I noticed a physiotherapist with a cough and a healthcare assistant with a cold. The only person to bat an eyelid at my coughing for the last two weeks was a Sister. She rewarded me with a dirty look, but said nothing. Despite frequent hand-washing, the likelihood is that I was infected by a colleague and my inconsiderate behaviour will have in turn infected many of my colleagues. The next person to use this keyboard will probably be infected, as will many others afterwards. Why have I come to work then?

If I stayed off work until free of infection, I would have been off for 3 weeks so far. I am afraid that I would have been marked as ‘a skiver’. In contrast, it seems to me that people that come to work when they are very ill (and highly infectious) are seen as heroes. Far from it, they are villains, just as I am a villain now. The right thing for me to do would be stay at home to protect other people from my germs, and not worry about what people think. Disregarding my sense of morality I have come to work to protect my reputation and career; this is purely selfish and does not reflect ethical reasoning becoming of a health care professional. This behaviour also neglects the likelihood that rest may have shortened my illness by increasing my ability to fight the infection. Why am I thinking like this?

It feels to me like NHS staff are being blamed for their sickness[1]. Smoking and obesity trends amongst NHS staff have for example been highlighted in the national press[2]. Well, I can honestly tell you that I have never smoked or been obese. Perhaps my sickness has more to do with working in a pathogen-rich environment with infected members of the public and staff that (just like me) continue to come to work even when they are sick. Being underpaid for the amount of stress I endure at work might also have something to do with it[3].

Speaking of high stress for low income leads me to reflect on work-life balance. Do you actually get any time for continuing professional development during your working hours, or do you do it at home? What about research analysis and all that other stuff we are expected to do? How often are you really given any time to do that at work? Are you expected to take your occupational therapy career home with you? Looking at some very basic health advice, I cannot even afford a mortgage (this is itself a significant risk factor for poor health[4]) so I am sacrificing my diet to save money (no 5 portions of fruit a day for me[5]), and as for 30 minutes of physical activity at least 5 days a week[6], errrm, do I have 2 and a half hours to spare? Perhaps, but at the moment I feel a little like the cardiologist I watched eating a full English fry-up for breakfast in the hospital canteen this morning. I find myself needing to drink Coca-Cola to get through my working day. I consider this to be caffeine abuse[7]. It is a sign that I am not taking enough rest. To top it off, after a particularly hard day at work, there is nothing I look forward to more than rich chocolate ice-cream and Armilar tawny port. These are maladaptive compensations for not having enough fun in my life and not being able to relax naturally. Occupational therapist, treat thyself!

References :
1. BBC (2006) NHS staff 'take more sick leave' Available from: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/5052160.stm Accessed: 10:01 18/2/2010
2. Walker P. (2009) NHS staff sickness rates 1.5 times private sector level, health report finds. Available from: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2009/aug/19/nhs-staff-sickness-rates. Accessed: 10:03 18/2/2010
3. Venth (undated) Occupational Therapy First - It is time for our profession to lead; not follow. Available from: http://www.metaot.com/blogs/%5Buser%5D-6 Accessed: 10:06 18/2/2010
4. Mailoo V.J., Abrahams P., Warner E., Wickham J. (2005) Council housing: getting what your service user needs. Therapy Weekly 31(29):11-14
5. NHS Choices (undated) Healthy eating self-assessment. Available from: http://www.nhs.uk/Tools/Pages/HealthyEating.aspx?Tag= Accessed: 10:10 18/2/2010
6. NHS Choices (undated) Fitness self-assessment. Available from: http://www.nhs.uk/Tools/Pages/Fitness.aspx?Tag=Fitness+tools Accessed: 10:15 18/2/2010
7. Hitti M. (2006)Caffeine Abuse: Buzz Gone Wrong. Available from: http://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/news/20061016/caffeine-abuse-buzz-gone... Accessed: 10:12 18/2/2010

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Member since:
6 November 2010
Last activity:
1 year 12 weeks

I could'nt agree more! As a student I feel an occupational imbalance yet in my curriculum we are constantly taught to help clients find their own occupational balance. Maybe our curriculun should include ways to achieve our own occupational balance? How can we teach others to find their "fit" when we ourselves have not found ours?

I feel being occupationally imbalanced can also effect the quality of services OT's can provide. Feeling overwhelmed and run down can impact anyones ability to perform their job to its fullest potential. If you are sick the ethical thing to do is to protect the client and find the time to get your life back to balance. UNfortunately, I feel all employees experience the same anxeity that if they take a few days off from work their co-workers will view them a certain way. However, it is essential to ensure you are balanced and also protecting yourself from getting even more sick and to also protect the clients you work from contracting what you have.

I love it!!! It is my sentiments exactly!! I have always affirmed the need for morning tea and lunch breaks and always took them in my last job (an Australian public hospital). I was feeling quite overwhelmed by the ailing health system in my state and had worked in it for a long time, so was quite demoralised and I felt quite justified in taking my breaks. Since having a child I now work in a private hospital where I still work really hard but the staff and organisation are really positive and the organisation is well funded. This makes a real difference! I have to say however that my occupational balance is more suited to me now. I only work 2 days and otherwise care for my 2 yo. I am fortunate as I really didn't like working 5 days. It will probably go back to that though years in the future, to pay off our hefty mortgage. Having had a child too has changed my perspective. I have alot less time to myself anyway so don't feel the stress of the busyness of work so acutely.

I totally agree... i think i should take the day off... to protect the patients of course :P
but on a serious note, i do think it is a point for consideration...

Having just joined meta-ot I was delighted to read this article and found myself nodding in agreeance the whole way through. Thank you for this entry, it was very thought provoking.